• Blog
  • Identity

Tackling the identity challenge: Why every publisher has 100% visibility on their audience

The days of tracking users across the internet are over.    As the industry reacts to the impact of regulation and browser developments on identity solutions, there are few important questions that we need to ask ourselves to remain focused on privacy — and ensure those that hold valuable first-party data, remain the owners of that data.     Firstly, any new solution needs to protect user privacy — ask yourself, does it replicate the world as it is today? Or does it improve privacy for the end-user? Equally, we need to consider how these solutions protect publisher data assets and value. For…

awaiting-image-permutive

The days of tracking users across the internet are over. 

 

As the industry reacts to the impact of regulation and browser developments on identity solutions, there are few important questions that we need to ask ourselves to remain focused on privacy — and ensure those that hold valuable first-party data, remain the owners of that data.  

 

Firstly, any new solution needs to protect user privacy — ask yourself, does it replicate the world as it is today? Or does it improve privacy for the end-user? Equally, we need to consider how these solutions protect publisher data assets and value. For example, does a solution allow the decoupling of data and inventory? And lastly, we also need to consider scale. Question whether a solution only works for a very thin slice of the Open Web or whether it provides scale and allows data targeting across the whole of the Open Web too.  

 

We believe identity is going to be replaced with Publisher Cohorts — a group of users that share some common attributes or behaviours within a publisher’s domain. Publishers can see 100% of their audience because they have a first-party relationship. And this allows them to make 100% of their audience available to advertisers — without using IDs in the bidstream. Without a user ID attached to bid requests publisher data does not leak out and it cannot be aggregated by downstream systems. This is great for the user’s privacy and great for the publisher. 

 

At AdExchanger’s Identity Day, part of its Innovation Labs event series, we were able to present our view on Publisher Cohorts and why this approach means publishers can make sure that the data that is generated in their environment is kept safe. 

 

To get a publisher’s point of view on the opportunities ahead, our VP, Americas, Kristy Schafer, spoke to Helin Lee, Audience Activation Lead at Vox Media. Here are a few quotes and highlights from Lee, and what that says about the future of advertising and privacy-by-design. 

 

Users want to be able to tell publishers when and how to use their data 

 

Vox Media is an early adopter of first-party data. Helin Lee said that regulation has shown that users want the ability to tell publishers how to use their data. The publisher wants to “step away from identifying users for the purpose of generating ad revenue.” She added: “We’d like to move forward with a technology that is not dependent on getting their personal information at a level that makes them feel scared.” 

 

Publishers need to evaluate what first-party data they have that makes them unique

 

For publishers looking to attract advertisers with their first-party data — and encourage buyers to be less reliant on third-party data — Lee had some advice. “It’s going to be first-party data that exists past the third-party cookie apocalypse,” she said. “What we want to start thinking about is, what do I have, what can I do with it, and how do I use this to set myself apart — not just for advertisers, but from a user experience too.”

 

First-party tests show reach is better

 

Vox Media has been busy developing its first-party data platform Forte, working with 100 different brands to test its offering, so far. Lee said: “We’ve run a few campaigns where we’re comparing [the performance of] our Forte ‘small, medium business owners’ segment to a third party segment, and post-campaign analysis shows that Forte data had better reach.” Lee puts this down to the fact that “Forte data is refreshed more frequently and it’s collecting data live.”   

 

Vox Media is using Forte “as a foundation to consciously build solutions that are morally correct,” and will continue to provide the best experience for its users, content generators, and advertisers. It’s this privacy piece that will need to be the focus. Identity solutions should protect user privacy and enable publishers to protect their data while generating revenue. 

 

For an inside view on Vox Media’s first-party data platform and a deeper dive on Publisher Cohorts, access the full presentation and Q&A below.



In this article
    You may be interested in
    Upcoming events & webinars

    The Data Collaboration Summit

    Learn More
    Upcoming events & webinars

    Let’s meet at DMEXCO 2025!

    Learn More

    Keep going, there's more to uncover.

    The Data Collaboration Summit

    With addressability declining, the Open Internet is under strain. The opportunity has never been greater to collaborate directly with premium publishers and tap into the power of their audience signals and media.

    Learn more

    Let’s meet at DMEXCO 2025!

    Expand your data collaboration and achieve incremental outcomes. Meet the Permutive team and let’s reimagine advertising together.

    Learn more

    Permutive and Ocado Ads launch unique audience targeting capabilities for publishers and advertisers to drive incremental outcomes

    Future, Immediate, The Independent and News UK join as inaugural publication partners. Permutive, the data collaboration platform powering the advertising ecosystem, is excited to announce a new partnership with Ocado Ads, the Retail Media Network of the UK’s fastest growing retailer. The collaboration means that publishers can now securely enrich their first-party data with Ocado’s extensive retail insights, creating unique targeting opportunities for brands and advertisers to achieve incremental full funnel outcomes on the Open Internet. The partnership builds on the 2024 launch of Ocado Ads, which offers the most complete data set in market…

    Learn more

    Permutive Data Collaboration Platform

    Expand your data collaboration and achieve incremental outcomes with Permutive's Data Collaboration Platform combining the capabilities of a DMP, a data clean room, and curation solutions.

    Learn more

    Data-driven publishing: How The Independent maximizes audience insights with Permutive

    Discover how The Independent leverages a data strategy powered by Permutive to transform audience understanding and boost advertising effectiveness.

    Learn more

    The hidden flaw in your data collaboration strategy (and how to fix it)

    Data collaboration is the accepted foundation for the next era of advertising. Across the industry, brands and publishers are investing in strategies to share data safely and drive performance. But a critical question remains: why are so many of these initiatives failing to deliver on their full potential? The answer often lies in a hidden, outdated assumption about the role of identity. For years, identity was the whole story. Today, relying solely on legacy IDs within a collaboration framework means your efforts are blind to over 70% of the open web, severely limiting your scale…

    Learn more